Evil killer ploughed into Scots bus driver, 23, after playing ‘yes or no’ game to decide his fate 

Evil killer ploughed into Scots bus driver, 23, after playing ‘yes or no’ game to decide his fate 

In a chilling case that has gripped Scotland, a man has been found guilty of the murder of a young bus driver after deliberately driving into the bus he was operating. The incident has raised serious questions about mental health, responsibility, and the devastating consequences of impulsive decisions.

The tragic event unfolded on the A77 at Fenwick, Ayrshire, when David Livingstone, 44, intentionally drove his work van into a Stagecoach bus driven by 23-year-old Gordon Stirling. The collision resulted in the untimely death of Stirling and injuries to two passengers, leaving a community in mourning.

Adding a disturbing layer to the case, it emerged that Livingstone had engaged in an online "yes/no" game shortly before the fatal collision. This detail has fueled speculation and debate about his state of mind and the extent to which he planned the deadly act.

The trial at the High Court in Glasgow revealed a complex web of personal struggles and questionable choices. Livingstone, who appeared in court in a wheelchair due to injuries sustained in the crash, denied intending to commit suicide and claimed to have no memory of the collision. However, the jury found him guilty of murder, rejecting his defense.

David Livingstone , who deliberately drove in front of a bus and killed the driver, Gordon Stirling, has been convicted of murder

The judge presiding over the case described the killing as the "most selfish" he had encountered in his decades in the courts, emphasizing the profound loss inflicted upon the victim's family and friends. The emotional impact of the crime was palpable in the courtroom, as Stirling's family members attended the proceedings, clutching an urn containing his ashes in a rucksack that once belonged to him, and wearing purple T-shirts, his favorite color, as a tribute.

The trial shed light on the events leading up to the tragedy. Days before the crash, Livingstone's long-term partner, Michelle, had ended their relationship. The couple's son, Devlin Livingstone, testified that his father had initially appeared "strong" but was later "shocked" by the breakup. In a poignant detail, Livingstone sent "love you" messages to his son and eldest daughter, Jada Hanvey, approximately 10 minutes before the crash, a gesture that both children found unusual and concerning.

Devlin expressed his worry upon receiving the message, stating that "texts like that usually lead to someone doing something bad." His apprehension proved tragically prescient, as Livingstone subsequently drove his van head-on into Stirling's bus.

Witnesses at the scene described the aftermath of the crash as "carnage." CCTV footage from inside the bus showed Stirling lying injured on the floor before emergency services arrived. One witness recounted comforting the young man by holding his hand. Sadly, Stirling succumbed to his injuries in the hospital.

Undated handout photo issued by Police Scotland of Gordon Stirling who died following a crash in Galston, Ayrshire. Issue date: Monday August 21, 2023. PA Photo. See PA story SCOTLAND Galston. Photo credit should read: Police Scotland/PA Wire NOTE TO EDITORS: This handout photo may only be used for editorial reporting purposes for the contemporaneous illustration of events, things or the people in the image or facts mentioned in the caption. Reuse of the picture may require further permission from the copyright holder.

During his hospital stay, Livingstone allegedly confessed to deliberately driving his van into the bus, imploring his ex-partner and her mother to keep the information secret. However, this confession was later presented as evidence in court.

Livingstone testified during the trial, acknowledging the breakup and his attempts to reconcile with his partner. However, he denied feeling suicidal and claimed to have little memory of the journey after leaving the ferry from Millport.

When questioned about the comment he made in the hospital, Livingstone vehemently denied that he had deliberately driven into the bus. He also refuted suggestions that he had previously spoken about taking his own life by driving into a bus or lorry.

The revelation that Livingstone had been using the website "Wheel Decide" on the day of the crime added another layer of complexity to the case. He described it as "a game for me, guessing yes or no," but denied that he was using it to decide whether to commit suicide.

24/08/2023 NINTCHDBJOBS000001047579 - Death of bus driver Gordon Stirling on A77 now treated as murder

Junction of A77/A719

The prosecutor, Mark Mohammed KC, challenged Livingstone's claim, suggesting that he had been "waiting for a bus to come the other way." Livingstone maintained that he did not remember waiting for a bus but did not believe he had been.

Further complicating the picture, it emerged after the verdict that Livingstone had a prior conviction for drug trafficking, highlighting a pattern of disregard for the law. Lord Mulholland, the presiding judge, deferred sentencing until October 29 in Stirling, emphasizing the severity of the crime and the "heavy price" Livingstone would pay.

Lord Mulholland underscored the tragedy of Livingstone's actions, stating, "It is tragic that you wanted to take your own life, but you took someone else's life. A young man with everything in front of him, loved by family and friends, who sat beside him for days as his life slipped away with the injuries that you inflicted on him. It is selfish in the extreme and you will pay a heavy price for that."

The case serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the devastating consequences of reckless behavior. It also raises crucial questions about mental health support and the need for individuals struggling with suicidal thoughts to seek help.

David Livingstone , who deliberately drove in front of a bus and killed the driver, Gordon Stirling, has been convicted of murder

This tragic event highlights the importance of open communication and seeking professional assistance when facing personal challenges. If you or someone you know is struggling with suicidal thoughts, please reach out for help. There are resources available to provide support and guidance during difficult times. Remember, you are not alone, and help is available.

The Samaritans offer free, confidential support 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. You can reach them by calling 116 123. Their website, https://www.samaritans.org/, also provides valuable resources and information.

The legal ramifications of this case are significant. The conviction of murder carries a mandatory life sentence in Scotland. However, the judge will determine the minimum term Livingstone must serve before being eligible for parole. This decision will take into account the aggravating factors of the case, including the deliberate nature of the act and the devastating impact on the victim's family.

Beyond the legal aspects, the case has sparked a wider conversation about road safety and the responsibility of drivers to operate vehicles with care and attention. The intentional nature of Livingstone's actions has raised questions about whether stricter regulations are needed to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

The grief and pain experienced by Gordon Stirling's family are immeasurable. They have demonstrated remarkable strength and dignity throughout the trial, honoring his memory and seeking justice for his senseless death. Their presence in the courtroom, wearing his favorite color and carrying his ashes, served as a powerful testament to the love and bond they shared.

The community has rallied around the Stirling family, offering support and condolences during this incredibly difficult time. The loss of a young life is always tragic, and the circumstances surrounding Gordon's death have only amplified the sense of grief and outrage.

As the legal proceedings conclude and Livingstone faces sentencing, it is hoped that this case will serve as a deterrent to others contemplating similar acts of violence. The justice system must send a clear message that such behavior will not be tolerated and that those who commit such crimes will be held accountable.

The legacy of Gordon Stirling will live on through the memories of those who knew and loved him. His family and friends will continue to cherish the time they shared with him and strive to honor his life by promoting kindness, compassion, and respect for others. While the pain of his loss will never fully disappear, his memory will serve as a source of strength and inspiration.