The debate rages on: Is Robert Sanchez, Chelsea's current goalkeeper, truly the caliber needed to lead the Blues to a Premier League title? Jamie Carragher, a respected pundit and former player, has stirred the pot with his assertion that Sanchez, along with the central defenders positioned in front of him, may not possess the championship-winning quality required to bring the coveted Premier League crown back to Stamford Bridge since their last triumph in 2017. This is a huge claim, and not one that Chelsea fans would be happy to hear.

Carragher's comments come after Sanchez's sending off during a match, a moment that reignited questions about his overall abilities and whether Chelsea might need to explore other options for the goalkeeping position. The position of goalkeeper is a key one for any team, not least one that is looking to challenge for the Premier League title.

Consider Liverpool's experience with Alisson Becker. His arrival proved transformative, and he's been instrumental in securing major silverware for the club. He is a world-class goalkeeper and one of the best in the Premier League. Great keepers can make the difference.

Looking at other teams at the top of the Premier League, David Raya may not have clinched any trophies yet with Arsenal, but there's a widespread perception that his presence elevates the team's performance. Do not underestimate the importance of a top-quality keeper.

Carragher, a Premier League legend who battled against some of the greatest teams in the history of the competition, didn't mince his words. His assessment of Sanchez was delivered with the force of experience. The question is, does his argument stand up?

Statistics, as it turns out, offer some support for Carragher's viewpoint. A closer look reveals that Sanchez's performance metrics don't quite align with the standard set by the goalkeepers at the clubs that finished higher than Chelsea last season. To win the Premier League, Chelsea must raise their standards.

Specifically, Sanchez doesn't seem to reach the levels of Alisson at Liverpool, or the standards set by previous Chelsea goalkeeping greats, Petr Čech and Thibaut Courtois, who collectively won five Premier League titles for the Blues. These are players who set the standard for excellence, and they are hard acts to follow.

Some data suggests that Sanchez might be more exposed by his defensive line compared to other goalkeepers, and even compared to past Chelsea goalkeepers. This can be looked at both ways, and needs to be considered carefully. Is it the keeper, or the defense?

However, the numbers also highlight a few areas where Sanchez's performance is demonstrably lacking. And these areas need addressing if Chelsea want to be successful. It all comes down to hard work on the training ground.

Since August 2024, Sanchez has committed five errors that directly led to goals. This is a concerning statistic, especially when compared to Raya, Alisson, and Ederson, with the Manchester City 'keeper having a spotless record in this regard. Goalkeeping errors can be costly, especially in tight matches.

Interestingly, both Raya and Sanchez have made the same number of errors leading to shots (10), but five of Sanchez's errors resulted in goals for Chelsea's opponents. This needs to be addressed by the coaching staff at Chelsea. Chelsea need to turn things around.

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL)

The difference may lie in the defensive support. It appears that Raya benefits from defenders who are more adept at cleaning up his mistakes, a safety net that might be less reliable in front of Sanchez. This is one area that Chelsea need to improve on.

The fact that Sanchez is forced to make significantly more saves than his counterparts could also be attributed to the quality of his defenders. Ironically, his save percentage is the highest among the four goalkeepers being compared. However, this is not enough on its own.

While Sanchez has conceded fewer goals than statistically expected based on the quality of chances he's faced (xG), Alisson, Ederson, and Raya all outperform their expected goals against metrics by a greater margin. These small margins are what can separate the very best from the rest.

As a consequence, Sanchez's goals conceded per 90 minutes is on par with Alisson, a title-winner, but lags behind Raya's rate. He needs to improve his goals conceded per 90 minutes.

The Spaniard also has the lowest passing accuracy among the group, falling considerably short of Alisson and Raya. This is not ideal for a modern keeper who is expected to take part in build-up play. The top keepers have great feet as well as great hands.

Sanchez's passing deficiency was a significant factor in Chelsea's pursuit of AC Milan goalkeeper Mike Maignan, highlighting the club's awareness of this weakness. Chelsea need to improve their defense to become a top-quality side.

Comparing passing statistics across different eras reveals the evolution of the goalkeeping role. Goalkeepers were not expected to be proficient passers or playmakers.

Only Courtois' passing accuracy in the 2016/17 season exceeds Sanchez's over the past year, showcasing a higher passing standard compared to previous Chelsea keepers. Goalkeeping has evolved as the years have gone by.

However, when it comes to the fundamental task of preventing goals, Čech and Courtois are in a different class, consistently demonstrating superior shot-stopping abilities. This is what they are paid to do, and needs to be remembered.

Čech's record of conceding just 15 goals in a Premier League season, set during José Mourinho's first season at Chelsea, remains unbroken, a testament to his exceptional goalkeeping and the defensive solidity in front of him. The importance of a solid defense is key.

In none of Chelsea's five title-winning seasons did the team concede goals at the same rate as they have with Sanchez in goal, further emphasizing the need for improvement if they aspire to regain the Premier League crown. The rate of goals conceded is of vital importance.

Of course, Sanchez isn't playing behind the same caliber of defenders as the likes of John Terry, Ricardo Carvalho, and Ashley Cole, legendary figures who formed an almost impenetrable shield in front of Čech during Chelsea's dominant years. Even the world’s best keeper needs a good defense in front of him.

Even the best goalkeeper in the world relies on a strong defense to protect him, highlighting the importance of a cohesive and well-drilled unit. It is not just down to the keeper; it is a team game.

Yet, even before Sanchez's costly error against Manchester United, doubts lingered about whether he possesses the consistency and reliability required to lift the Premier League trophy with Chelsea. Can he turn things around and improve his game? Only time will tell.